We have stopped in many times.They also have delivery. Tasty Pizza...Crispy. Not thick.But not exactly thin. Friendly but tables were meant for the the fast in/out. Atmosphere is pure pizza kithen.

Sometimes it's a hit or miss, most of the time the food is excellent and pizza is really a neighborhood classic. But 4 stars because there are some off days.

Justinos is my local go to pizzeria where I live in Richmondtown... they're reasonably priced and seem to be pretty consistent with their pies. Haven't had anything else but their pizza for the most part, so I can't speak for the entrees or appetizers, but they make a darn good pie. They make a real nice Chicago pie too.

If you order on the days the owner Justin is there you will taste the best pie you ever tasted, especially the Sicilician.. All other days its good but 4 stars, when he is there Fridays - Sundays you will love the slice you are eating

the best sicilian pie on staten island

You must be right. My home delivery order of a 12 slice L and B Style Sicilian and large round "Old Fashioned" pizzas, both ordered "well done," were 2 of the best pies I have tasted. They were perfectly cooked, and very delicious.